Društvene pretpostavke ostvarenja zajedničkog europskog sigurnosno-obavještajnog sustava - Teorijska raščlamba govora E. Macrona

master's thesis

• Title (english): Social Assumptions Behind the possibility of the Realization of a Common European Security-intelligence System – a Theoretical Analysis of the Speech by Emmanuel Macron
• Author: Josip Bilić
• Mentor: Danijela Lucić (mentor)
• Committee member: Mirko Bilandžić (predsjednik povjerenstva)
• Committee member: Kruno Kardov (član povjerenstva)
• Granter: University of Zagreb; Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences; (Department of Sociology); Zagreb
• Defense date and country: 2021-06-21, Croatia
• Scientific / art field, discipline and subdiscipline: SOCIAL SCIENCES; Sociology

Abstract

Cilj ovoga uratka bit će raspraviti ideju te predstaviti neke od društvenih pretpostavki za ostvarenje zajedničkog europskog sigurnosno-obavještajnog sustava. Riječ je o teorijskom radu gdje se rasprava gradi oko tri dimenzije: prva uključuje smještanje Macronova govora unutar dvije teorijske paradigme, druga predstavlja širu raspravu o državi, a koja uključuje tri osnovna pojma: država, nacija-država i Europa, dok posljednja dimenzija uključuje realističko-konstruktivističku raspravu temeljenu na iskazanim saznanjima o pojmu 'država' te na primjeru Macronova govora. Unutar rasprava je prepoznato kako je nužno kombinirati realističke i konstruktivističke elemente, jer konstruktivistička želja za ignoriranjem moći i sukoba, a realističko ignoriranje ostalih izvora moći (osim vojnih i ekonomskih), otežavaju objašnjenje mogućnosti društvenih promjena. Također, povratak osnovnim idejama ovih studija upozorava na potrebu preispitivanja vlastitih pristupa, kao i na potrebu za daljnjim razvijanjem spoznaja oko “samorazumljivih“ pojmova baš kao što su država, nacija-država ili Europa. Zaključno, ukupna rasprava je pokazala i protuslovlje unutar Macronovog europskog projekta, a koje proizlazi iz nemogućnosti etabliranja konstruktivističke ideje izvan, još uvijek dominantno, realističkog svijeta sigurnosti.

Abstract (english)

The aim of this paper is to discuss the idea of the common European security and intelligence system and to present some of the social preconditions needed for its realization. The paper is a theoretical work in which the discussion has three dimensions: the first one is about placing Macron's speech within two theoretical paradigms, the second represents a broader discussion about state (and encompasses three basic terms: state, nation-state and Europe), while the last dimension contains realistic-constructivist discussion based on the knowledge gained regarding the term "state" as well as the example of Macron's speech. In the discussions, the necessity of combining realistic and constructivist elements is acknowledged because constructivist desire to ignore power and conflict, as well as realistic disregard for other sources of power (with the exception of the military and economic ones), make the explanation of possible social changes more difficult. Furthermore, the return to the basic ideas of these studies calls for reconsideration of one's own approach and also points to the need for the further development of the perception of "self-evident" terms such as state, nation-state or Europe. In conclusion, the overall discussion also demonstrated a contradiction present within Macron's European project, which is a consequence of the inability to establish constructivist ideas outside of the realistic world.

• Keywords: europska i nacionalna sigurnost; Macronov govor iz Sorbonne; realizam i konstruktivizam; država; nacija-država; Europa
• Keywords (english): european and national security; Sorbonne speech of Macron; realism and constructivism; state; nation-state; Europe
• Language: croatian
• URN:NBN: urn:nbn:hr:131:958552
• Study programme: Title: Sociology (single major); specializations in: Research; Course: Research; Study programme type: university; Study level: graduate; Academic / professional title: magistar/magistra sociologije (magistar/magistra sociologije)
• Type of resource: Text
• File origin: Born digital
• Access conditions: Open access
• Created on: 2021-06-28 08:17:44