Značenjske razlike među različitim izdanjima istoga prijevoda prispodobe Isus kod Zakeja

master's thesis

• Title (english): Differences in meaning between different editions of the same translation of the parable of Jesus in Zacchaeus
• Author: Klementina Svetec
• Mentor: Zrinka Jelaska (mentor)
• Committee member: Suzana Coha (predsjednik povjerenstva)
• Committee member: Igor Marko Gligorić (član povjerenstva)
• Granter: University of Zagreb; Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences; (Department of Croatian language and literature); Zagreb
• Defense date and country: 2022-07-20, Croatia
• Scientific / art field, discipline and subdiscipline: HUMANISTIC SCIENCES; Philology; Croatian Studies

Abstract

U ovome se diplomskome radu raščlanjuju razlike u 27 različitih prijevoda istoga teksta, dijelu Evanđelja o Luki u kojemu se govori o odnosu Isusa i Zakeja. U uvodu se raspravlja o nazivima povezanima uz grane jezikoslovlja, posebno o semantici i njenim podvrstama, što se povezuje s problemima u prevođenju u jeziku i u književnosti. U drugome dijelu rada iznose se cjeloviti prijevodi te opće razlike među prijevodima prema dosad objavljenim istraživanjima (npr. Jelaska 2008, Babić 2018, Mihić 2012, Barševski et al. 2020), uključujući prevođenje biblijskim ili kakvim drugim stilom. U trećemu dijelu rad se bavi značenjskim razlikama kako bi se usporedile semantičke značajke te semantičke razlike koje utječu na različito razumijevanje teksta. Razlike se raščlanjuju redak po redak kako bi se dobio uvid u cjelovit tekst i odredile značenjske razlike među različitim izdanjima. Pokazuje se koliko različiti prijevodi, zbog odabira različitih leksičkih i gramatičkih rješenja, drugačije grade značenje pa se pokazuju različiti pogledi na isti događaj, ali i dobiva dojam da događaj nije isti, nego da su to različiti događaji. U četvrtomu se dijelu posebno raspravlja o šest različitih prijevoda šestorice autora, od kojih svaki autor ima barem četiri ili više različita izdanja. Uspoređuju se prijevodi istoga autora, uključujući i prijevod Gracijana Raspudića zbog usporedbe s prijevodima Ljudevita Rupčića u izdanju iz 1961. Usporedbom sa svim ostalim prijevodima donose se zaključci o tomu jesu li različita izdanja jednoga autorskoga prijevoda doista inačica jednoga, prvoga ili prethodnoga prijevoda, ili pak novi prijevod.

Abstract (english)

This dissertation analyses the differences between 27 different translations of the same text, the part of the Gospel of Luke that describes the relationship between Jesus and Zacchaeus. The introduction discusses the terms related to the branches of linguistics, especially semantics and its subtypes, which are associated with translation problems in the fields of language and literature. The second part of the paper presents complete translations and general differences between translations according to previously published research, including translations in the biblical or any other writing style. In its third part, the paper deals with semantic differences in order to compare semantic features and semantic differences that cause different understandings of the text. Differences are broken down line by line to gain insight into the full text and determine semantic differences between different editions. It is shown how different translations, due to the choice of different lexical and grammatical solutions, create different meanings, so different views on the same event are shown, but they also give the impression that these are several different events based on the mentioned one. The fourth section discusses six different translations by six authors, each with at least four or more different editions. The translations of the same author are compared, including the translation by Gracijan Raspudić for the purpose of comparison with the translations of Ljudevit Rupčić in the 1961 edition. By comparing them with all other translations, conclusions are drawn as to whether different editions of an author's translation are really a version of one, first or previous translation, or a new translation.

• Keywords: Lukino evanđelje; sinonimi; prijevodi; inačice prijevoda
• Keywords (english): Luke’s gospel; synonyms; translations; translation versions
• Language: croatian
• URN:NBN: urn:nbn:hr:131:336907
• Study programme: Title: Croatian Language and Literature; specializations in: Linguistics, Literature, Teaching; Course: Linguistics; Study programme type: university; Study level: graduate; Academic / professional title: magistar/magistra hrvatskog jezika i književnosti (magistar/magistra hrvatskog jezika i književnosti)
• Type of resource: Text
• File origin: Born digital
• Access conditions: Open access
• Created on: 2022-07-20 10:10:44